AVALANCHERS ~ View topic - Godflesh

Guest

Inspired by the ND thread then.

Here's how it goes. Order the albums from worst to first - send to me by Private Message - I'll tot them up, and it keeps everyone's ratings outside of influence and sway.

In the event of a points tie, then highest-rated by an individual(s) will separate.

I'll post them up as and when.

Guest

Godflesh
Streetcleaner
Pure
Selfless
Songs of Love and Hate
Us and Them
Hymns
A World Lit Only By Fire

Guest

EP, no?

haha, separate thread to debate? Wink

I always considered it an album, discogs considers it thus

Guest

Funny, I was talked around to it being an EP over on the old forum way back when, my originally taking it to be an album.

Fuck it, I'll include it then.

I'll send my list tomorrow...this should be interesting...

The Selfless twonks will all over this one, no doubt.

Twonks.

Hymns, Us & Them, the worst

Songs of Love and Hate

Cold World

Streetcleaner

Pure

Merciless

Slavestate

Tiny Tears

Selfless

Godflesh

Guest

It's a blind vote, so edit that and send by PM.

Member Joined: 05 Sep 2006 Posts: 1004

Is Love & Hate In Dub included?

Guest

No - as it's a remix album. See post two for what's included.

We should discuss that the 4 extra songs/abominations that are not part of the original vinyl print of Streetcleaner are not considered part of Streetcleaner.

It is my opinion that they should not be considered at all in fact, but I will settle if we can agree on the above statement, that is, that they should not be considered part of Streetcleaner.

Guest

I'm happy enough with that - fwiw I like them in their own right but never consider them part of the album.

Streetcleaner's almost the worst Godflesh album.

Guest

Trying to keep this a blind vote lads, so if you could leave it out of the thread and just PM your worst to firsts, that would be ideal.

Member Joined: 10 Sep 2006 Posts: 11897 Location: istanbul

i will try to not post in this thread.

. Joined: 02 Sep 2006 Posts: 4464

I think it will be pointless either way now, Golz..

.. as 'theredhog', has asked me to delete their account, because, I refused to delete 'desu evol yaw' posts without 'desu evol yaw' permission to do so.

. Joined: 02 Sep 2006 Posts: 4464

Alas, I'm not kidding.

I haven't deleted 'theredhog's account yet, as, I give people a 24hr period from the time of request, just in case people wish to change their mind.

Bummer

Huh?

Member Joined: 08 Oct 2010 Posts: 226

theredhog if you are reading: why not just disregard any lists posted in the thread?

If he doesn't come back we will forever wonder what the definitive GF worst to first list is.... Embarassed

Even though we all know Selfless would have been first... Cool

redhog-- it'd be great if you stuck around. we like having you here and value your contribution.

if you decide to head out, cheers and good luck with everything.

On the serious side, +1 on what Josh said.
Sincerely.

I like theredhog but isn't this a bit dramatic?

. Joined: 02 Sep 2006 Posts: 4464

Perhaps, he just had a bad day, Doomy.

Everyone has days that they'd rather forget for whatever reason.

. Joined: 02 Sep 2006 Posts: 4464

I've been about man, just lurking. Spending time at other places on tinterwebz and trying very hard to write an album... haha that last one isn't quite going to plan Smile

Member Joined: 21 Oct 2006 Posts: 1580 Location: moon

theredhog, don't go, not much of the internet remains that is like avalanchers

Well said BassTotem!

Perhaps all of us who PM'ed theredhog could post their worst to best in here now? And we can argue the merits of Selfless again.

But just remember... JKB prefers Pure to Selfess lol

WHO THE HELL IS THIS JKB DOOD? WTF DOES HE KNOW ABUT GODFLESH? HAS HE EVEN SEEN THEM OR IS HE ONE OF THESE JESU FANS?

FFS!!!!

RAGING RIGHT NOW.

Rolling Eyes

i did speak to him once and he said he considered changing the title from "selfless" to "shameful" after listening to what they had recorded whilst obviously not in their right minds Twisted Evil